Main Menu

 

30) THE PUMPKIN MAN – c.1860 – Mid-America

by D.B. Anderson

An “Adonis Surrey, Esq. – Gentleman Safecracker” Series Tale

Copyright © 2004 D.B. Anderson All rights reserved

 

     At first light of dawn, after the horrific fire had totally devastated Osgood Bentley's wagon and furniture factory, Adonis and Flurrie felt it somewhat unseemly to even consider stealing gems or paintings from his mansion.  They discussed it over a breakfast of buckwheat pancakes drenched in melting freshly churned butter, maple syrup, sizzling bacon, black coffee and a huge piece of cooled pumpkin pie.  The Hotel Platte dining room was near deserted at nine in the morning.  The morning chief was a short heavy-set young woman, blond-haired, blue-eyed, wearing a constant smile and continuously hummed some sort of a lilting Scandinavian fjord melody.  She appeared to be in her early twenties and she made no effort to hide the fact that she had her eye on Flurrie. 

     "I understand you are an artist, Mr. Peoples," she said with a very slight Nordic accent, pouring them a second cup of the wonderfully odorous coffee, and as she poured she leaned her ample twin peaks into Flurrie's shoulder.

     Flurrie's hand trembled as he attempted to eat another bit of his pie.  "Yes!"

     "He is quite an excellent artist," Adonis quickly spoke trying to cover his friend's obvious state of fluster.  "Why not ask him to sketch your lovely face?"

     Flurrie quickly gazed up at her.  "I will be pleased to profile you."

     She began to giggle.  "My name is Hedda.  I finish work at ten-thirty this morning.  I can wait for you in front of the hotel." 

     Flurrie waived his right hand in a negative gesture.  "We have several appointments to sell railroad stocks and bonds today.  Perhaps tomorrow."

     She covered the cheeks of her face with her hands.  "I am so impressed!  You sell stocks and bonds and are also an artist!"  She suddenly blushed.  "I'll wait for you at ten-thirty tomorrow morning.  I will send the drawing home to my parents in Bergen, Norway." 

     Suddenly the hotel manager appeared at the table.  Hedda glanced at him in discomfort and quickly moved back to the kitchen. 

     "Gentlemen," the manager spoke placing two slips of paper on the table in front of Adonis.  "I have two enquiries from the placard I had made up for your Adonis Surrey, Esq. Agency.  I believe you said I will receive ten dollars per potential client I bring you."  He then dramatically motioned to the two slips of paper on the tabletop.  "I would appreciate being paid as I present you with the prospects."

     "Ten dollars per lead?" Adonis questioned.  The hotel manger glanced away feigning indignity.  Adonis slipped a twenty-dollar bill from his vest pocket and placed it on top of the two slips of paper.  "We appreciate your help."

     The manager beamed with delight.  "Anything I can do for you gentlemen.  Anything at all.  I have many contacts.  I am at your service."

     Adonis nodded.  "Thank you.  We will be in contact.  Do keep up the excellent work."  The manger quickly tucked the twenty-dollar bill in his coat pocket and scurried back to his office. Adonis gazed at Flurrie and chuckled.  "My original deal with him was for five dollars per sales lead but maybe we can use him for other tasks in the future.  We have to keep our foot soldiers happy."

     Flurrie nodded in agreement.  "Righto, now just what pray tell is your Lordship's decision on the Bentley mansion heist?  Tonight?  Tomorrow night?"

    Adonis chuckled again.  "You know I have to do this, don't you?  I totally despise the uncaring rich."

     "Yes," Flurrie replied in an empathetic tone.  "Especially after their kind so disgracefully ruined your father's business in Boston."

     Adonis actually pounded his fist on the tabletop.  "And also stripped him of his pride.  They are total filth, working young children and adults to death in their factories and I take great pleasure in depriving them of the most treasured items from their collections."

     "I'm with you.  You know that," Flurrie replied somewhat surprised at his friend's sudden outburst.

     "I apologize.  It is something festering in my very soul."  Adonis said, taking a deep breath.  "I'll check on the mansion tonight to see how long the lights are burning, what the ingress and egress is and so forth."

     "Osgood Bentley mentioned his wife is visiting her mother in Chicago but he will certainly be home." 

     "Yes," Adonis agreed, "but he will probably be tired out from planning to rebuild his wagon factory after the terrible fire.  Let's work the heist tomorrow night.  I'll notify Ol' Johnny to have his carriage ready."

     Flurrie suddenly beamed with pleasure.  "Not to forget, I have the appointment this morning with Paul Parnassus at The Dab Hand Gallery.  I'll be taking my art work in for the showing he is setting up for me on next weekend."

     "Excellent.  Let's have breakfast again tomorrow morning and confirm our plans."  Adonis smirked, glancing back at the kitchen area.  "Perhaps Hedda will give you an extra portion of pumpkin pie."

     "Hmmphh..." Flurrie groaned arising and moving to the lobby and up the grand stairway to their quarters on the second floor.

     Flurrie scurried around the suite as he gathered up his eight paintings and twenty sketches and he carefully wrapped them in a bed sheet, tying its four corners into a type of carrying handle.  He placed the sack over his back and merrily made his way out of the suite and almost danced down the winged stairway to the lobby. 

     The Manager stood in complete confusion as he watched his esteemed guest laboring under the weight of the bulky bundle.  "Might I obtain some help for you, Mr. Peoples?"

     "No, no," Flurrie gaily responded.  "I'm just fine, and I'll return your bed sheet later."

     The Manger glanced away with a smug look and muttered to himself.  "Common salesman..."

     Flurrie spent the rest of the day helping Peter Parnassas paint the walls of his Dab Art Gallery in a ferocious puce colored deep dried blood shading which he guaranteed would gather the attention of the guests to Flurrie's atmospheric paintings and breathtaking portrait sketches of twenty exquisite women he had randomly sketched.  Flurrie then helped Paul to frame and hang his artwork and while so doing they drank copious amounts of a Greek mountain wine and Paul sang passionate Grecian songs.  Flurrie left the gallery at about eight in the evening and stumbled down the street to the Platte Hotel just several doors away.  

     He woke up in the middle of the night in complete darkness.  He arose from the bed and tripped on something, falling to his knees.  A door suddenly opened forcing in an intruding beam of blinding light.  Flurrie glanced up at the outline of a rotund silhouette. 

     "Are you all right, Mr. Peoples?  You fell down the hotel's winged stairway three times.  I heard the commotion and carried you into my room here at the rear of the hotel."

     'Hedda!" Flurrie exclaimed. 

     She reached over and easily lifted him to a standing position, keeping her arm around his waist to steady him.  "I will help you to your suite now." 

     Flurrie shook his head.  "I am so embarrassed.  I usually don't drink like that.  I was at The Dab Hand Art Gallery down the street and helped set up my exhibit for next week's showing, and..."

     "Easy...  Take a deep breath.  I'm here to help you," she lovingly consoled.

     He glanced down at her arm around his waist steadying him from falling again.  It felt marvelous, exciting.  The scent of lilac wafted from her blond hair.  He then noticed the bed he had arisen from.  "Perhaps if I could lie down a bit longer..."

     Hedda laughed, backing away from him.  "No, no. It's time for you to go up to your suite," she chuckled, opening the door to the hallway.

     "Will you help me upstairs?"

     "I think you are doing just fine now," she said with a smile.

     Flurrie began to limp.  "I think I've twisted my ankle.  I'm quite lame.  You wouldn't throw a lame man out?   I am in horrible need!"

     "So am I," she chuckled, poking her head outside her room to the empty back hallway of the hotel.  All was quite.  Flurrie stuck his head out to see what she was looking at and she pushed him back into her room.

     At five in the morning she made him go up to his suite.  "I have to prepare the kitchen ovens and pots and pans for breakfast.  Hurry up to your room before someone discovers us together.  I can't afford to get fired." 

     Flurrie wrapped his arms around her full body caressing and kissing her.  She returned the emotion and then pushed him out the door.  "I'll see you later, my little Kringle." 

     A knock on his bedroom door woke Flurrie from a sound sleep.  The sun was blazing in the window.  He heard Adonis voice on the other side of the door.  "Let's forget about breakfast this morning.  Let's meet here at eleven tonight and discuss our midnight appointment."

     "Very good," Flurrie responded in relief, tucking his aching head under the pillow.

     Adonis and Flurrie departed the Platte Hotel at eleven-thirty that night dressed in black clothing.  They were silent as they strolled to the end of the block where Ol' Johnny was waiting with his carriage to transport them to their appointed heist.  Just a few blocks West of their location the nightlife district was in full swing with raucous piano music serenading not only the drinkers, gamblers, and love makers, but also everyone else in a several block area.

     “Noisy lot,” Flurrie mumbled.

     Adonis pointed upward.  "Clear skies, full moon lighting everything in its path.  Disgusting weather.”

     Flurrie chuckled.  "Mother Nature has no consideration for thieves in the night."

     Ol' Johnny waived down to them from his driver's seat.  After they comfortably settled themselves in the carriage Adonis tapped his walking cane on the frame of the carriage and they were quickly and almost silently transported along several side streets to the tree lined mansion row of Omaha.  Ol' Johnny slowed the carriage as they passed the Osgood Bentley mansion. 

     "There is our destination.  Italianate white stucco walls," Adonis commented.  "The house is dark."

     Ol' Johnny stopped the carriage under an aged oak tree with its limbs spreading far and wide to provide a perfect hiding place in the shadows of night.   Adonis and Flurrie moved along a perimeter line of hedges offering them some secrecy and then the duo quickly made their way to the rear garden area of the Bentley mansion.  In a matter of a seconds Adonis had jimmied the lock of the French doors and they found themselves in a medium-size room containing books, stuffed wild animal trophies, and a wall displaying hunting rifles, knives, and swords.

     "Very impressive," Flurrie mumbled.

     “Don't be too impressed.  His type usually does this for show only," Adonis responded cynically. 

     They methodically searched the room for a wall safe, but found none.  Suddenly a strange shadow appeared and then disappeared at the outside the French doors.  It was a short very rotund figure, wearing a top hat with a feathered plume.  They quickly hid behind an overstuffed leather-covered sofa.  The roly-poly figure moved swiftly and methodically through the room to the hallway door, listened at the door, then opened it and silently disappeared.  They gazed at each other in complete astonishment.

     "Incredible,” Adonis whispered.  “It's our competition...the Pumpkin Man.  Let's stay put.  I wish to see what he does next.”

     Within five minutes the rotund figure made its way back through their proposed heist area, and through the open French doors.  The figure moved very swiftly for its size and shape through the Bentley backyard and they visually followed his silhouette through several adjoining backyards, its form curiously silhouetted by the light of the full moon.

     Adonis shook his head.  "Well, old chum, there is a first time for everything."

     "This is totally unbelievable," Flurrie responded almost too loudly.

     "Now back to the business at hand," Adonis ordered, moving to the fireplace.  "There is an old adage amongst us cracksmen; When there is no wall safe, check the fireplace."

     "What?" Flurrie questioned.

     Adonis began running his hands over the finely carved mahogany just below the mantelshelf of the fireplace.  His fingertips moved quickly and expertly over the carved hunting scene running the length of the fireplace.  He then began to move his fingers down the right side molding and then he stopped short.  He smiled as he pushed on a short section of the molding and a hidden drawer slid open just under the mantelshelf.  He quickly reached in and removed a small cloth sack and slipped it into his pocket without viewing the contents.   

     "Hurry," he whispered.  "Let's rush from here.  Danger is in the air."

     They swiftly and silently exited the French doors, leaving them wide open on purpose, and began moving along the perimeter line of hedges to the street.  Suddenly a light brightened an upper window of the mansion.  They scampered to Ol' Johnny's waiting carriage and were quickly transported from the scene.

     Adonis poured he and Flurrie a very large brandy as they rested on the couch in the security of their sitting room in the Presidential Suite of the Platte Hotel.  Neither even bothered removing their outer suit jackets.

     "Cheers," Adonis toasted, raising his glass. 

     Flurrie nodded in agreement, raising his glass.  "To our encounter with the infamous Pumpkin Man."  Flurrie then paused.  "Curiously, the scent of lilacs seemed to flow behind him as he passed us in the dark.  Did you catch the scent?"

     "Yes indeed.  A very distinct garden scent but then being a pumpkin his home would be in a garden somewhere," Adonis teased.     

     "Good Lord, man!  Aren't you awash in the mystery of it all?"

     "Righto, but first let's see what we have here," Adonis questioned, reaching into his suit coat pocket and slipping out the small cloth sack he had purloined from the concealed drawer in the Bentley fireplace.  He eagerly poured out several mixed size gems, including two very large diamonds.  "All easily worth one hundred thousand dollars or more.”   He then stared seriously into Flurrie's widened eyes over the sight of the gems.  "I must admit I have a very curious feeling about this entire heist."  He looked away.  "I can't explain it."

     "Do you think we were taken advantage again by the committee?  As was the case when we purloined the Prussian Royal Family jewels from Paul Schmidter, the brewery owner?"

     "Perhaps.  We did heist his jewels without knowing we were being guided into it by the committee.  He wanted his jewels purloined so he might receive the insurance money.  What irked me was the fact that all the committee had to do was ask us to do the job, but instead engaged in subterfuge.  They had to prove they have a superior control over us."

     "Yet, we made out all right on that.  We received our 20% of the jewelry value.  It was business as usual."

     Adonis raised the index finger on his right hand.  "That may be it.  We are becoming far too casual about all of this."  Adonis wagged his finger in a scolding manner.  "If caught we would be the ones going to jail for several years.  We would be the individuals standing there with out fists full of purloined jewelry.  The committee, whom ever they are, would not be involved in the least bit.  And we might be sequestered for ten to twenty years rotting our young manhood away."

     Flurrie shuddered.  “What do you suggest?"

     'We have been rather lackadaisical in committing our heists.  Let's plan them out in greater detail, including what to do if one or the other of us gets caught.  Let's formulate a contingency plan for each heist.  And I despise saying this, but lets do carry our Derringers at all times incase violence would ensue."

     "I don't like the sound of that!" Flurrie stated in a somewhat rattled tone.  "I don't know if I would care to injure anyone during a heist!"

     "Don't misunderstand, we may most certainly continue doing things as we have been but with the addition of the prospect for violence.  I am quite apt with my walking cane and you certainly are proficient in bare-knuckle boxing, and we will have our Derringers for back up.  That should take care of any unforeseen bumps in the night."

     Flurrie released a deep sigh.  "I hate this kind of discussion.  It takes the romantic adventure out of being a society thief.”

     Adonis sipped from his brandy and then smiled.  "We do have the advantage of operating in the frontier settlements of our country in its move west.  The law is basically loose and they are far more interested in jailing drunks and bank robbers, rather than a pair of sophisticated jewel thieves as ourselves."  

     Flurrie gulped on his brandy.  "Valid point," Flurrie agreed, taking another gulp of brandy.  "Every job has its pitfalls.  One must be alert at all times."  He then shook his head.  "Money wise, I can't believe I have several thousands of dollars hidden in my sock drawer and all accumulated in the last few months."

     Adonis suddenly chuckled.  "Not your sock drawer, of all places."

     Flurrie broke into laughter.  "Just joking; some Canadian humor.  I certainly don't mind telling you that I keep my profits hid in my derelict appearing wooden paint kit.  No one would bother stealing the scratched paint smeared wooden box."  He paused.  "I obtained the idea from the totally disreputable sea chest you keep in your office in Milwaukee.  I remember when the draymen first brought it; I thought it was some sort of mistake.  You informed me that you kept it because if a thief saw it standing on a railway depot platform that he would pass it up for some expensive appearing luggage." 

     "Disguise is always useful," Adonis mused, pouring them each another glass of brandy.

     "Speaking of disguises..." Flurrie inquisitively commented.  "This Pumpkin Man is really a very incredible chap.  He is short, squat, fast on his feet."

     “Perhaps HE is a SHE," Adonis reasoned, sipping his brandy.  "Remember the scent of lilacs when IT passed us in the dark?"

     Flurrie suddenly froze in place.  "Lilacs!"

     Adonis grinned.  "Now what?"    

     Flurrie excitedly pointed in a downward motion.  "Her!  She!"

     "Calm down, man!  You'll have a stroke," Adonis warned, patting Flurrie on his right shoulder.  "Easy..."

     "Hedda wears a lilac scent in her hair.  She is short, a bit heavy set, in great physical condition."

     Adonis broke into laughter again.  "Well, you would certainly be the authority regarding her physical stamina."

     Flurrie pounded his fist on the tabletop in front of them.  "This is serious!  And it all fits.  The physical description.  Her agility..."

     "Do go on..." Adonis teased, leaning towards Flurrie.  "I want a full dossier of her prowess."

    Flurrie then nervously joined in the laughter beginning to feel the effect of the third brandy rolling down his throat.  "Laugh, but I'm the one that can brag that I stayed the night with the infamous Pumpkin Man."

     Adonis broke into uncontrollable laughter reaching out and shaking Flurrie's hand.  "Congratulations, old chum.  I’ll make sure that is published in the gossip column of the local paper.”

     Flurrie then became meditative.  "I must investigate this further.  I do like Hedda...quite a bit."

     "She is very lovely,” Adonis said.  “And if she is this Pumpkin character she does it quite well."

     Flurrie gazed intently at Adonis.  "I will not rest until I know."

     "If I can help out in any way, do let me know.  There is an old saying that it takes a thief to catch a thief."

     Flurrie nodded.  "I just may call on you.  I need time to cipher this out."

     "What of your one man show at the Dab Hand Gallery?  Is it all set for next Saturday night?  I've asked around about the gallery owner Peter Parnassas and I understand he is quite a promoter and salesman, and panders to the distaff side of the local gentry."

     Flurrie beamed with pleasure.  "There is another strange aspect of all of this.  By becoming a thief my art career has positively flourished." 

     "Propinquity, old chap, and my motto Confidence wins the day!"

     At eight the next morning Flurrie rushed down to have breakfast in the Platte Hotel dinning room extremely anxious to converse with Hedda.  He lay awake for the last few hours laboring over the fact if she was indeed the Pumpkin Man thief or not.  He wondered how he might extract the information from her without giving away the fact that he and Adonis were also thieves, crouched behind the couch in the very room she entered to commit her petty theft.  The lilac scent of her hair was unforgiving.  Yet, he found it impossible to say nothing at all.  He had grown very fond of her.  Yet again, was it any of his business?  Hedda was delighted to see him gazing intently in her direction.  She scurried to his table.

     "Where have you been?" she asked in a whisper.  "I've been watching for you."  She pretended to write up his breakfast order on her pad of paper.  "I have something extremely important to discuss with you.  It is frightening."  She then glanced up to see the hotel manager arrive at the front desk.  "The vulture has arrived."

     Flurrie began to turn around to see whom she was talking about.  "Extreme importance?  What vulture?"

     "No, no!  Don't turn around.  It is the manager.  Meet me in the rear of the hotel at ten-thirty this morning.  I have to see you."  She paused, her expression falling into despair.  "Flurrie, I know..." she said, as she drifted to the kitchen door.

     "You know?  I'm the one that knows!"

     The manager then entered the dinning room and sat at a table in front of the bay window facing the Platte River.  He nodded his head to Flurrie in acknowledgment.  Flurrie nodded back.  Hedda silently served Flurrie a full breakfast of scrambled eggs, sausages, mashed potatoes soaking in melted butter, coffee and a piece of warm Danish pastry.

     Flurrie sniffed in her direction as she served him.  "I love that scent of lilacs in your hair," he whispered.

     "Not now," she whispered in return.  She then remained very business-like treating him as a customer only. 

     Flurrie stood near the back door of the hotel at ten-twenty and waited in immense indecision for her to exit.  He wondered again if he should confront her as being the Pumpkin Man thief or not.  It was probably all some fantastic coincidence.  At exactly ten-thirty the door swung open and she ran to Flurrie burying herself in his arms.  "We must speak of something.  Let's stroll from here."

     She was still wearing her white chief's dress but had placed a black velvet jacket over her bodice and she wore a tan straw hat with a short black feather tucked into its navy blue ribbon band. 

     She gazed up in a mixture of confusion and disappointment.  "Are you a common thief?"

     "What are you talking about?"

     "Flurrie I saw you and your partner running along the hedges of the Bentley mansion last night.  I also saw him jimmy the lock on the French doors and then you two entered the study room."

     Flurrie's face flushed red.  "Then you are the Pumpkin Man. It was the lilac scent from your hair that gave you away.  You should be more careful!"

     She paused.  "Strange, I never gave my perfumed hair a second thought."  She then stopped short, grasping Flurrie's right arm.  "You were in the Study Room in the dark?"

     "Adonis and I were crouched behind the couch, but if you knew we were in the house why did you enter?"

     Hedda's forehead wrinkled.  "I don't know.  I hoped to see what you two were up to."

     Flurrie stopped short and took Hedda in his arms.  "This is absolutely insane.  Hedda, I love you."

     She began to cry.  "I'm frightened, and I love you.  Let's walk down by the river.  We have a lot to talk about."

     Flurrie kissed her and then snuggled his head next to her head.  Suddenly a wagon full of men passed them and they whistled and teased as they waived their hands and arms at the lovers.  Flurrie and Hedda broke into laughter and ran towards the river.

     The next day Flurrie felt decidedly nervous in facing his friend, confidant, and partner Adonis with the news that he had confessed to Hedda their side venture of being society thieves.  Secondly, he would also partake the news that Hedda was the local almost legendary Pumpkin Man thief.  Thirdly, he would also tell his friend that he and Hedda were in love.

     Adonis sat silently as Flurrie spewed forth the news items in a rambling, jittery tone.

     "Please say something.  I have betrayed you, dear friend."

     "No.  No, not at all," Adonis responded picking up his walking cane.  He began fencing with his imaginary foe.  "She certainly is your type."

     "I am very serious about her."

     Adonis shook his head in doubt.  "She now knows we are thieves, and we have verified she is a thief."

     "It balances out, doesn't it?" Flurrie asked.

     "I guess it does at that," he agreed, staring into Flurrie's confused eyes.  "Flurrie, I'm afraid I have some terrible personal news.  I have received a telegram from my mother that my dad has passed away."

     "Oh, no!  Adonis!" Flurrie said in shock placing his arm over his friend's shoulders.  "Terrible news!  I am so sorry."

     "I am leaving for Boston tonight.  I may be gone for at least four months.  Will you maintain the railroad stock and bond agency until I return?"

       "I will take care of everything on this end.  Not to worry.  Take all the time you need."    

     "I will be back," Adonis stated in a positive tone.  "I would prefer to be alone now."      

     "Most certainly." 

     “I'm afraid I will miss your art gallery opening night this Saturday."

     “Hedda and I will see you off at the station."

      "No.  I prefer to be left alone."

     Flurrie backed away from Adonis in respect.  "Hedda would like to meet you."

     "When I return.”

     "I'll leave you then.  I'm taking her on a picnic near the river."

     Adonis grinned ever so slightly.  "Good luck, old friend.  I shall enjoy trading theft tales with her when I return."  He reached over and shook Flurrie's hand and then entered his bedroom and closed the door almost silently.  

 

Download Permission:  You may create electronic files, or print copies of the above short story for your personal use.  You may not use the short story in a ‘for sale’ venue.  Copyright date and origination information, including author’s name, must accompany all downloads.

 

‘Dust Webs’ Mystery Magazinewww.apex-ephemera.com

Email: mysteryshortstories@yahoo.com

Address to: Editor